Article · 6 min read

Virtual CISO or a full-time hire?

A comparison of cost and coverage for operators with fewer than 500 staff, and a third option that many small utilities use.

What NIS2 asks for

NIS2 does not use the word CISO. Article 20 makes the management body approve the security measures, supervise them and take part in training. Article 21 lists the measures. Somebody must own the programme, keep it moving and report to management. That person can be on the payroll, part-time from outside, or a mix.

So the question is not "do we need a CISO?". It is "how many days of senior security work do we need each month, and who does the rest?".

Count the work, not the title

For a mid-sized operator, the security work usually splits into two kinds:

  • Senior work, a few days a month: the roadmap and priorities, reports to the board, the regulator and auditors, supplier contracts, decisions during an incident.
  • Daily work, a part of someone's week: account reviews, vendor access requests, patch decisions, backups, the asset list, training reminders.

The daily work belongs inside the company, with people who know the plant. The senior work needs experience that small operators rarely have in-house, and they do not need it every day.

Side by side

Full-time hireVirtual CISO
TimeAbout 220 working days a yearA fixed number of days a month, often 2 to 6, more during an incident
Time to startMonths: experienced OT security leads are scarceWeeks
CostSalary, employer costs, training, recruitment, every monthA monthly retainer for the days you use
ExperienceOne person's backgroundA person who has done the role elsewhere, often across several operators
Knows your plantYes, after some monthsPartly, so an internal coordinator is needed
RiskKey-person risk if they leaveLess presence on site, so contract scope must be clear

Senior security leaders are among the best-paid people in IT. In Germany, recruiters report CISO base salaries of about €180,000 to €280,000. A small utility will not pay that, but it will still compete with banks and IT firms for the same few people.

The third option: a coordinator and a virtual CISO

Most operators under 500 staff that we work with use a mix:

  1. Name an internal security coordinator. Often an automation or SCADA engineer, with 20 to 30 percent of their time protected for security. They know the plant, and the operators trust them.
  2. Add a virtual CISO for the senior work. A few fixed days a month for the roadmap, the board, the regulator and suppliers, and extra days when something goes wrong.
  3. Plan the handover. The virtual CISO coaches the coordinator. After two or three years, the coordinator can grow into the role, or you hire with a clear job description and a programme already in place.

When a full-time hire is the right answer

  • Security work fills more than about three days a week, every week.
  • You have many sites, several control systems, or a security team to lead.
  • You must have someone on site at short notice, every day.
  • You are an essential entity with frequent audits and a large supply chain.

If you need 24/7 monitoring, neither option is enough. That is the job of a security operations centre. A virtual CISO can help you choose one.

What a virtual CISO does in a month

  • Keeps the roadmap current and decides what can wait.
  • Writes the quarterly report for the board and briefs management.
  • Is the point of contact for the authority and the auditors, and keeps the evidence ready.
  • Reviews supplier contracts and remote access rules before you sign.
  • Leads decisions and the 24-hour early warning during an incident.
  • Coaches the internal coordinator.

Five questions to ask a virtual CISO

  1. Have you done this job on the operator side, in OT, and for how long?
  2. Do you sell products, or take commission from vendors?
  3. How many days a month, and what happens during an incident?
  4. How will my team run this without you in three years?
  5. Can I see a sample of a board report you wrote?

Where to start

Take the NIS2 readiness check. It shows which areas need the most work, which is a good guide to how many days you need. Then book a 30-minute call, and we will tell you which option fits, including when the answer is a hire and not us.

Salary figure: Optima Europe, CISO salary benchmarks for Europe. This article is general guidance, not legal or employment advice.

Not sure where you stand on cybersecurity and regulations?

Book a 30-minute call. Tell us about your operations. We tell you if we can help, and when we cannot.