Why do it now
Ask your shift supervisor: "If ransomware hits the office tonight, what do you do?". Then ask the managing director the same question. If the answers differ, you have found the reason for an exercise.
NIS2 asks for incident handling, business continuity and crisis management, and for ways to check that your measures work. The 24-hour early warning is also a decision that someone must make under pressure. An exercise is the cheapest way to test all of this before it is real.
Who to invite
- Operations: the operations lead and one experienced shift supervisor.
- Automation: the SCADA or automation engineer.
- IT: the head of IT.
- Management: the managing director or the person who can decide to isolate the plant and to report to the authority.
- Communication: whoever talks to customers, the municipality and the media.
- Optional: your main integrator, and legal or the insurer contact.
Eight to twelve people is enough. More than that, and the quiet people stop talking. You also need a facilitator who is not part of the team, and one person who writes everything down.
The day
- Morning, two hours: prepare. The facilitator and the operations lead adapt the scenario to your plant: real system names, real people, real vendors.
- Late morning, three hours: the exercise. Walk through the scenario in stages. Stop at each stage and ask the questions.
- Afternoon, one hour: the debrief. List what worked and what was missing. Give each gap an owner and a date.
- Next day: a two-page summary for management, with the gaps and the plan.
A first scenario: ransomware on a Friday evening
Use one scenario only, and keep it realistic. This one fits most water and energy operators. The facilitator reads each stage aloud, called an inject, and then asks the questions.
Stage 1. Friday 18:30
The office helpdesk reports that several PCs show a ransom note. Email is down. The shift supervisor sees no problem in SCADA yet.
- Who is told first, and by whom? Who decides what happens next?
- Do we disconnect the control network from the office network? Who can decide that at this hour?
Stage 2. Friday 19:15
The historian copy in the DMZ is encrypted. One HMI in the control room is slow and shows an unknown login.
- Do we keep the plant running, switch to manual, or stop safely? What does manual operation need, and for how long can we hold it?
- Which integrator has remote access right now, and how do we switch it off?
Stage 3. Saturday 09:00
The SCADA server will not start. The last backup that anyone tested is from last year.
- Who restores what, from where, and how long does it take? Where are the licences and installation media?
- Who decides that this is a significant incident? Who sends the 24-hour early warning, and when does the clock start?
Stage 4. Saturday 14:00
A journalist calls. A customer posts on social media that the water pressure is low.
- Who speaks for the company, and what do we say? Who informs the municipality?
- What do we tell staff, and what must they not say?
Rules for the room
- No blame. The exercise tests the plan, not the people.
- No fixing during the exercise. Write the gap down and move on.
- Decide, do not discuss forever. If nobody can decide, that is a finding.
- Use real names and numbers. "Somebody from IT" is not an answer. Who, and what is their phone number?
After the exercise
Make a short table: the gap, what to do, who owns it, and by when. Typical first findings are:
- Nobody is sure who may isolate the control network.
- The phone numbers are only in the email system that is down.
- The backup of the SCADA server was never restored.
- The early warning has no owner, no deputy and no template.
- An integrator connection was open that nobody remembered.
Check the list at the next management meeting, and run the next exercise in a year with a different scenario, such as a vendor account used at night.
Common mistakes
- A scenario that is too easy. If nobody feels uncomfortable, nobody learns.
- Only IT in the room. The hard decisions are in operations and management.
- No decision-maker. Without the person who can isolate the plant, the exercise stops at the first real question.
- No follow-up. A list of gaps without owners is a list of things that will go wrong.
Where to start
Free scenario packs exist. The US agency CISA publishes tabletop exercise packages, including one for water and wastewater, that you can adapt. Our30-point OT security checklist has the exercise as point 30. If you want a facilitator from outside your team, book a 30-minute call.
Scenario packs: CISA Tabletop Exercise Packages (CTEP). This article is general guidance, not legal advice.
